It begins: Happy families are all alike; every unhappy family is unhappy in its own way.
It is painful from the outset in a way that you can't get at by watching the movie. I knew the facts: there are two central couples: Anna/Alexy and Kostya/Kitty. My vague recollection was Bad vs. Good, Passion vs. Intellect, etc and then at some point near the end: Anna throws herself in front of a train and dies. Reading the book, I was drawn in, I experienced real emotion -joy, grief, revulsion, horror- no longer a mere observer.
I was horrified by Anna's transformation from a good woman of society into a wretched wreck. What was horrific was how much I have ever been Anna (no, not in adulterous sense). I have been Anna in her rages and recriminations, with her jealousies and coveting. I have been Anna. Halfway through the book, seeing that she could not stop herself and knowing that there was a train coming, I began to flinch whenever Tolstoy would lead me back to the sordid disaster of an existence that is Anna Arkadyevna. I would speed through her pages half urging her to just hurry the hell up and end it and other times begging her to just stop, turn around and go home to her son.
I was horrified by Anna's transformation from a good woman of society into a wretched wreck. What was horrific was how much I have ever been Anna (no, not in adulterous sense). I have been Anna in her rages and recriminations, with her jealousies and coveting. I have been Anna. Halfway through the book, seeing that she could not stop herself and knowing that there was a train coming, I began to flinch whenever Tolstoy would lead me back to the sordid disaster of an existence that is Anna Arkadyevna. I would speed through her pages half urging her to just hurry the hell up and end it and other times begging her to just stop, turn around and go home to her son. It was the passages about Kostya, particularly as he and Kitty drew closer and closer together, that made it possible to get through the text. Kostya's mental turmoil and judgements, fair or otherwise, were an oasis amidst the harsh environment created by Vronsky and Anna. They reflect the best and most wonderful versions of me or rather there are shadows and glimpses of their love in me, in my marriage. Their innocence and tenderness and even their ridiculous arguments transported me back to the first year of my marriage. Kostya's struggle as an unbeliever and his wife's certainty that his love of neighbor made up for whatever disbelief he might actually have were sweet and touching. I know what it is to struggle with belief and yet to be smacked flat with the fact of Christ, laid bare by the Church's truth. I know the devil that teases and dances in the thoughts of Konstastin Dmitrievich. How hard it is for him to surrender; how hard it has been for me to surrender! Yet, he does.
Part 8 of the book was spurned by Tolstoy's editor and was first introduced when the author paid for the book to be published. Had we been left simply with Anna's desolation, her despair, the tragic triumph and defeat of her final act, the book would not be the masterpiece that it is. It would have left us dull, cold . . . as hopeless as she. I dare say the final paragraph makes the entire work for me something wholly new, hopeful, even lyrical. Levin leaves us with these thoughts to ponder and reconcile:
Part 8 of the book was spurned by Tolstoy's editor and was first introduced when the author paid for the book to be published. Had we been left simply with Anna's desolation, her despair, the tragic triumph and defeat of her final act, the book would not be the masterpiece that it is. It would have left us dull, cold . . . as hopeless as she. I dare say the final paragraph makes the entire work for me something wholly new, hopeful, even lyrical. Levin leaves us with these thoughts to ponder and reconcile:
"This new feeling has not changed me, has not made me happy and enlightened all of a sudden, as I had dreamed, just like the feeling for my child. There was no surprise in this either. Faith — or not faith — I don't know what it is — but this feeling has come just as imperceptibly through suffering, and has taken firm root in my soul."I shall go on in the same way, losing my temper with Ivan the coachman, falling into angry discussions, expressing my opinions tactlessly; there will be still the same wall between the holy of holies of my soul and other people, even my wife; I shall still go on scolding her for my own terror, and being remorseful for it; I shall still be as unable to understand with my reason why I pray, and I shall still go on praying; but my life now, my whole life apart from anything that can happen to me, every minute of it is no more meaningless, as it was before, but it has the positive meaning of goodness, which I have the power to put into it."
If you have not read the book, go get it. And if you have, read it again. Yes, I know I spoiled the ending for you, but honestly this is such a beautiful examination of people and their suffering. Tolstoy truly knows the human spirit and I dare say you will see aspects of your life reflected in these pages.





